Forget the days when the ranks of first-year medical students were mostly filled with recent college graduates who majored in chemistry, biology or another one of the hard sciences. Today’s medical students comprise perhaps the most diverse assembly schools have ever seen.
This emerging trend is a reflection of evolving standards for medical school admission, which have grown to focus on requisite
skills instead of conventional backgrounds. It’s an approach that third-year student Peg Bicker is happy to embrace. Bicker, who hails from the aforementioned world of sculpting and who possesses both a bachelor’s and master’s of fine arts from Emporia State University, finds more similarities than you might think between the two fields.
“It’s helpful to have a background in something with a high degree of uncertainty,” Bicker said. “The materials and knowledge are different, but you still are able to find the solution for your current situation.”
Bicker’s journey to medical school began with a joke at a cocktail party. Chatting with another guest, she mused that if for some
reason her sculpting career didn’t succeed, “there’s always medical school.”
“We both laughed, but then I thought ’why not?’” Bicker recalls. “The idea wouldn’t die, so I started doing research and then took some classes.”
While Bicker made her way to medical school in a relatively circuitous way, for fellow third-year student Anne Hogsett, the dream of being a doctor was ever-present, but consistently delayed. Hogsett worked for decades as an engineer before finally pursuing her medical dreams.
“I majored in chemistry, but I always knew I wanted to be a doctor,” Hogsett said. “My husband and I got married two weeks after college graduation, and from there we always had to work and raise our kids.”
While working a series of engineering jobs, including the production of wastewater treatment systems and raising her family, Hogsett realized that the dream of becoming a doctor had not faded with time.
“In 1999, my husband asked if I still thought about med school, and I said ‘of course,’” Hogsett said. “So I took one class a semester for seven years, subjects like Chem 1 and Organic 1, and now here I am.”
Both Bicker and Hogsett agree the challenges were intimidating, particularly when it came to relearning basic pre-medical skills. All of the changes and revolutions in scientific fields were overwhelming.
“When I studied genetics in 1981, we only had pea plants and redeyed flies,” Hogsett said. “We couldn’t imagine mapping the entire
human genome.”
“The sheer amount of information is unbelievable.” Bicker said. “You have to take it one step at a time, but each step gets a little easier to take.”
When students with an unconventional academic background enter medical school, they often find themselves in a maelstrom of competitiveness they haven’t experienced in the past. They can also be tagged with the “nontraditional” label.
One could make the case that, with the evolving opinion of what constitutes a promising future physician, no medical student is truly traditional these days. More and more medical students are chucking the conventional college-to-grad-school path in favor of work experience, family life, or some combination thereof. And with that trend comes a whole new set of evaluation criteria. “Nontraditional students bring a breadth of experience that many younger applicants simply don’t have, just based on their ages,” said Sandra McCurdy, MEd, associate dean for admissions at the KU School of Medicine. “If they are undertaking such a major life change, we need to determine if they have the best skills. Are they good communicators? Do they have the necessary maturity
and drive?”
The School of Medicine routinely receives applications from hopefuls in their 40s and 50s, but age is neither a qualifying nor a disqualifying factor. McCurdy said the goal is to assemble the best and most diverse class possible. “If accepting a certain student helps us add to the learning environment of the class, then it doesn’t matter how old that student is,” She said. “We look for motivation, passion, and understanding as part of our admissions criteria.” Just as top universities spent the 1990s moving away from a strict focus on academics and toward a holistic view of the applicant as more than just a student, so too are graduate and professional schools rethinking the admissions process.
“Has an applicant thought about much more than excelling in chemistry and physics?” McCurdy asked. “Has he or she been broadly exposed to a variety of subject matter? A medical student needs to be thoughtful enough to look at multiple sides of an issue.”
For many students, the gap between college and professional school provides much-needed introspection and a welcome respite from
education – but makes for a harder adjustment upon return to school. “The volume of material is the hardest adjustment,” Hogsett said.
“It’s like drinking water out of a fire hydrant, or treading water in the high seas. There’s just no such thing as solitary study time.” One of the most refreshing aspects of nontraditional students is their almost studiously self-effacing manner. Many of them shy away from recognition and brush aside praise. Call it the wisdom of age or the humility of experience – it’s something Jim Stanford has in spades.
Stanford, at age 51, the oldest male student at KU Medical Center, says he is just thankful for the opportunity to attend medical school.
After a brief flirtation with medicine nearly three decades ago, Stanford worked in the computer industry for 28 years. Now, after
doing graduate work in biology at Wichita State University, he says it is time to realize his long-held dream of becoming a doctor.
“It’s one thing to talk about doing something, and it’s another to step in and do the work. I decided I was ready to do the work, and medicine is the new frontier,” Stanford said. “I really couldn’t be happier right now.” He, like many nontraditional students, recognizes the limitations of his status and is not out to be the top student. It’s just not practical, he said, given the commitment he has to his wife and four children.
Nontraditional status has social implications as well, but the students have found bonding with younger, traditional students to be easier than envisioned.
“My class is great. I’ve made some great friends, and I’m just so proud to be one of them,” Hogsett said.
Support from family and friends is crucial for nontraditional students in what may be the most frenzied and demanding time of
their lives. Both Bicker and Hogsett said their husbands have been “wonderful,” and the other students they have met have made the tough adjustment to medical school smoother.
But if the encouragement from family and friends or the blinding desire to become a physician isn’t enough to keep these unusual
medical students going, it helps to have a sense of humor. “We have to laugh every day,” said Hogsett. “Not at the expense of anyone else, just at ourselves. We have to laugh at ourselves or we’d go crazy.” +